VM Packet Capture Considerations

When running a virtual machine (VM) to capture network data, there's a potential problem that can arise due to network offloading. This is a specific issue related to capturing network data in a virtualized environment. Network offloading can be likened to missing pages in a notebook; when you capture packets without network offloading, it's like having a complete set of notes with all the necessary information. But when network offloading occurs, it's as if some crucial pages are missing or not present, making it harder to understand the original context and intent.

What Happens?

1. Network Offloading: Many modern network cards and VM hosts support network offloading, allowing the NIC or host to handle certain aspects of the TCP protocol stack on behalf of the guest VM.

2. MSS (Maximum Segment Size): The MSS is a parameter that specifies the largest amount of data that a device is willing to receive in a single TCP segment. While MSS itself is not altered by offloading, offloading can impact how TCP segments are handled, potentially obscuring details in captured traffic.

3. VM Network Stack: The VM’s network stack, specifically the virtual NIC, handles TCP segments. Disabling offloading within the VM ensures that packet capture tools see traffic as it is truly handled by the VM without NIC-induced alterations.

4. Impact on Captured Traffic: When offloading is enabled, the virtual NIC or the host might process packets differently, altering their structure in ways that are not reflected accurately in packet captures.

The Impact

• Altered Packet Handling: Network offloading features like TSO and GRO can segment or reassemble packets in ways that make captured data appear differently than the actual traffic flow, which can complicate analysis and debugging.
• Obscured TCP Details: Important TCP details, including segment boundaries, can be masked by offloading, making the captured data less representative of true network behavior.

This can lead to challenges when trying to analyze or debug network problems, as the captured data may not accurately represent the true network behavior.

Disabling Offloading

To disable offloading within a VM, use the following command:

sudo ethtool -K eth0 tso off gso off gro off lro off rx off tx off sg off ufo off rxvlan off txvlan off rxhash off

Explanation

• ethtool: A command-line utility used to display and change the settings of network interfaces.
• -K: Specifies that you want to modify the offloading settings of the network interface.
• eth0: The name of the network interface being configured. Replace eth0 with your actual network interface name.

Offload Settings and When to Use Them:

1. tso off (TCP Segmentation Offload): Disables the NIC’s ability to segment large TCP packets into smaller ones.
   Use When: You need to capture and analyze TCP segments exactly as they appear on the network without NIC modification, crucial for accurate protocol analysis or troubleshooting TCP connections.

2. gso off (Generic Segmentation Offload): Prevents the NIC from segmenting large packets for any protocol, not just TCP.
   Use When: You need precise packet captures across multiple protocols and want to avoid any NIC-induced segmentation.

3. gro off (Generic Receive Offload): Disables the NIC's merging of incoming packets into larger segments.
   Use When: Individual packet visibility is essential for analysis, such as troubleshooting performance issues or when accurate traffic flow reconstruction is necessary.

4. lro off (Large Receive Offload): Prevents the NIC from combining multiple received TCP segments into larger packets.
   Use When: You require precise, segment-by-segment capture of incoming TCP traffic, especially when analyzing server performance or debugging application-level issues.

5. rx off (Receive Checksum Offloading): Disables offloading of checksum calculations for incoming packets, requiring the system's CPU to handle it instead.
   Use When: You need to validate checksums manually during packet analysis or to ensure that corrupted packets are accurately captured and flagged.

6. tx off (Transmit Checksum Offloading): Disables offloading of checksum calculations for outgoing packets, making the system's CPU perform this task.
   Use When: Similar to receive checksum offloading, this is useful when validating the integrity of outgoing traffic, especially when debugging applications that generate unusual or custom packet structures.

7. sg off (Scatter-Gather Offload): Disables the NIC’s ability to handle fragmented data by splitting and reassembling data into segments.
   Use When: Precise capture of fragmented data is critical, particularly in performance-sensitive environments or when working with applications that manipulate data streams at a low level.

8. ufo off (UDP Fragmentation Offload): Stops the NIC from handling fragmentation of UDP packets, making the CPU handle fragmentation instead.
   Use When: Required for analyzing UDP traffic as it is transmitted without NIC alteration, especially useful for debugging streaming services or other real-time applications.

9. rxvlan off (Receive VLAN Acceleration): Prevents the NIC from offloading VLAN tagging and untagging for received packets.
   Use When: Accurate capture of VLAN-tagged traffic is required, particularly important in multi-tenant environments or when troubleshooting VLAN-specific issues.

10. txvlan off (Transmit VLAN Acceleration): Disables the NIC’s handling of VLAN tags on outgoing packets.
    Use When: Necessary when analyzing VLAN-tagged traffic from the source device to ensure tags are applied and transmitted as expected.

11. rxhash off (Receive Hashing Offload): Disables the NIC’s packet steering, which uses hashing to distribute incoming packets across CPUs.
    Use When: You want to ensure that packets are captured and processed in their arrival order without NIC-induced distribution that can alter analysis.

When to Use All Offloads

• Packet Capture and Analysis: When performing packet captures, especially in security or performance analysis, disabling all offloading ensures that the data you collect is unaltered by NIC optimizations.
• Debugging Network Issues: Accurate reproduction of packet flows and protocol behaviors, crucial for identifying problems in TCP/IP or application layers.
• Virtual Environments: When working with VMs, offloads can obscure traffic behavior, so disabling them helps to ensure that the virtual adapter reflects true traffic patterns without modifications.
• Compliance and Security: In regulated environments, ensuring that captured data reflects true on-the-wire traffic can be critical for compliance audits and security assessments.

Verifying MSS Values in a PCAP

To verify that the MSS values were captured correctly, you can inspect the TCP headers of the SYN and SYN-ACK packets using the following commands.

Using tcpdump

1. Capture packets including TCP options to see MSS values in SYN and SYN-ACK packets:

   tcpdump -nr your_pcap_file.pcap 'tcp[tcpflags] & (tcp-syn) != 0'
   

   This command filters SYN and SYN-ACK packets, which typically contain the MSS option in their headers.

2. Inspect the captured MSS values:

   tcpdump -nr your_pcap_file.pcap -v | grep "mss"
   

   Explanation

   • -n: Tells tcpdump not to resolve hostnames or port numbers.
   • -r: Reads from the specified pcap file.
   • -v: Increases verbosity to show TCP options, including MSS.

Using tshark

1. Open tshark and filter to show SYN and SYN-ACK packets that include MSS values:

   tshark -r your_pcap_file.pcap -Y "tcp.flags.syn == 1 || tcp.flags.syn == 1 && tcp.flags.ack == 1" -T fields -e tcp.options.mss_val
   

2. Display the MSS values captured in SYN and SYN-ACK packets:

   Explanation

   • -r: Reads from the specified pcap file.
   • -Y "tcp.flags.syn == 1 || tcp.flags.syn == 1 && tcp.flags.ack == 1": Filters SYN and SYN-ACK packets to check MSS options.
   • -T fields -e tcp.options.mss_val: Extracts the MSS value from the TCP options field.

Either of these tools' commands allow you to verify that the MSS values were captured as they appear in SYN and SYN-ACK packets, ensuring that they were not modified by network offloading.

---